Sour soccer saga as another coach leaves

Inside Story Archives

By.  EDWARD THANGARAJAH Bangkok Post

The Football Association of Thailand (FAT) has done it again. The dismissal of Brazilian coach Carlos Roberto Carvalho for the second time was shocking and reflects sadly on the country's soccer administration.

It once again confirms the ignorance of some who are short-sighted and expect results overnight.

When the services of English coach Peter Withe were terminated, I asked in this column how the national soccer team, which was being groomed in the European style of the game, could suddenly change over to the Brazilian style of play.

Carvalho, who was at that time anxious to take over from Withe, said that he was accepting the post with open arms and was ready to deliver. His enthusiasm and anxiety for the job seemed to have blinded him to reality.

It was only later that he realised that it is almost impossible to produce a team here which is capable of making an impression.

The FAT has a notorious reputation of firing and hiring coaches and it found an excuse to get rid of the Brazilian, claiming that he hadn't produced results.

Carvalho wasn't given enough time to educate Thai players in the samba style of soccer, which enabled Thailand reach the semi-finals of the Asian Games in Beijing in 1990 under him, having beaten a number of strong teams including hosts China in the quarter-finals.

That was when Carvalho was Thai coach in 1990s. He was later shown the door when Thailand lost the SEA Games final against Indonesia on penalties.

Coaches need time to train teams, to pick and choose players for the right positions and to convert them into stars. They cannot produce champion squads overnight.

But that's what the country's soccer administrators want. They dismissed Withe for that reason, even though he had proved his worth, producing results all the way.

The FAT also showed the exit door to German coach Burkhardt Ziese who had transformed a national team that was beaten at home by Indonesia into a champion side in the SEA Games, thrashing the same Indonesian squad en route to winning the gold.

Many coaches have endured this unhappy situation over the years.

As the saying goes, Rome wasn't built in a day. That's what our soccer administrators should bear in mind. It is easy to sit on your haunches and to make adverse comments on coaches and sack them.

The late Pravitr Chaiyasarm, who coached the Thai side which won the gold medal in the 1981 SEA Games in Manila, picked most of his players from the then champion club team Rajpracha which he was training.

Hence he knew his players well and there was no need to build team spirit and train them for a long period of time. All what he needed was a good striker and he picked Piyapong Pue-on for that spot.

The FAT must give the coaches they hire time and encouragement to create good teams. It must give up its habit of hiring and firing coaches. This has happened to many coaches, especially those hired from abroad. They are kicked around like a soccer ball by administrators, which is not good for the promotion and development of the sport and hurts the good name of Thailand.

That's why soccer isn't doing well, other than winning regional competitions.

Soccer administrators must treat coaches like human beings. It is easy for them to claim that coaches have left amicably, as was said after the dismissal of Carvalho.

Money and power isn't everything. People have to be humane and act with greater understanding. It is a great pity that Thailand, which has so much sporting talent, is unable to produce good soccer players, though some of the country's players are playing elsewhere.



I was surprised to see Filipino Randy Rangubhat picked to fight defending world flyweight boxing champion, Pongsaklek Wongjongkam, in an over-weight warm-up on Friday in Phuket.

Anyone with a knowledge of boxing would never have selected such a tough opponent for Pongsaklek who has been recovering from a bout of chicken pox and was weak health-wise, especially for a showpiece bout.

It was a bad mistake by those handling the flyweight champion.